Equities Surge Amidst Better Than Expected April Jobs Report 

Equities surged on Friday following the release of a better-than-feared April Jobs Report, calming worries of an imminent recession. Troubled regional banks rallied by over 70% in some cases, even as bond yields rose. Nonetheless, any optimism surrounding the regional banks may be short-lived as more bank failures are expected. This is due to the Federal Reserve’s decision to keep short-term interest rates higher for longer, which will put pressure on all but America’s biggest banks to raise deposit rates and scale back lending.

As borrowers realize that a 5%+ short-term U.S. Treasury bill is a much better return than keeping money in their bank, we’re seeing a movement of money out of banks designed to slow economic growth and cool off demand. The question remains: how long of a lag does Fed policy come with? Some on Wall Street believe that inflation and interest rates will fall dramatically within the coming months. We take the more conservative view that it will take a longer time for interest rates to decline and inflation to move back down to 2.00%. We don’t see the need to raise interest rates further, but we are taking the Fed at its word that rates will remain elevated for longer.

State of the Mortgage Market

Despite the challenging market conditions, the mortgage market is functioning well. We’re creating many new relationships with lenders we’ve not pursued doing business with or known of until recently. Here’s a sampling of some interesting products on active deals we’re working on in both the residential and commercial space (yes, Insignia Mortgage does commercial loans too!):

• Single-family home loans of up to $4MM at 80% loan-to-value with rates in the mid-5s for ARM loans
• Single-family home loans of up to $30MM at 70% loan-to-value with rates under 5% with a banking relationship
• Owner-occupied commercial loans of up to $10MM with rates in the mid-5s
• Multi-family apartment loans of up to $15MM with rates in the mid-5s

Fed Maintains Rate Hike Path Due To Jobs Report 

An in-line Jobs Report will keep the Federal Reserve on hold until its next meeting in May. As a result, market forecasters predict there will be another .25 bp rate hike to 60%. Wage inflation continues to normalize, which is a welcome sign, while job growth in the private sector has slowed. The unemployment rate fell to 3.500%, which suggests the job market is still too tight, especially with the approximately 10 million jobs left unfulfilled. Viewing the economy based on the jobs picture, the economy is proving to be much more resilient than many had thought. This is despite the almost 500 basis points tightening in such a short period.  

Yet, there are other economic metrics flashing warning signs. This includes a crucial aspect, the de-inverting yield curve. Also, of concern is the senior loan officer survey which confirms our day-to-day view that bank underwriting is tightening up. There has been an increase in consumer debt and an uptick in auto loan defaults. In addition, keep in mind the recent bank failures. They have not only passed the panic phase but will also continue to impact bank underwriting of risk. This remains a very confusing market and we certainly do not have a crystal ball. Nonetheless, the risk of a recession or of a recession already in its early phase remains high. Oil moving up over 80 per barrel does not help those with brighter expectations. 

Some of you are wondering why mortgage rates continue to remain elevated despite the 10-year Treasury falling to around 3.35%. There are several reasons for this, but the most promising is the average spread of Bank Rates for 30-year mortgages moving to nearly 3.33% over the 10-year Treasury. Should that spread tighten to the low of 1.35%, 30-year mortgage rates would be closer to 4.75% -5% rather than the 6.00% to 7.00% many banks are offering. The demand by investors for a bigger spread on mortgage loans is very much affecting the ability of potential borrowers to qualify for home mortgages. This is also why Insignia Mortgage spends a considerable amount of time meeting with various smaller to mid-sized banks who are willing to sharpen their pencil on loan terms, as opposed to seeking large banking relationships on larger jumbo loans. The goal is to partner with a resource that offers commonsense decisions on loan approvals. It is precisely this optionality that makes the mortgage broker model so important in today’s particularly challenging marketplace.